Amish Farm Stay


We hope you enjoy reading these reviews and comments from our guestbooks. If you have stayed at one of our guesthouses please consider submitting a review of your visit. Look for more reviews on this website at the bottom of the individual pages of some of our lodgings.

Google Reviews:

You may read more reviews on our Amish Farm Stay Google page which you can find at this link.

Submit your review

Create your own review

Amish Farm Stay
Average rating:  
 60 reviews
by Tim on Amish Farm Stay
October 2019
Review title: Wonderful Family and Guesthouse
Stayed At: Killdeer Farm

We had a wonder stay at the Killdeer Farm with the Esh Family. The hospitality was beyond what we expected. The 3 level guesthouse was nicely renovated with plenty of rooms that provided hot water for showers, electricity, gas stove, refrigerator and plenty more. We felt completely safe the entire time we were there. We will definitely book with the Killdeer Farm's Esh Family again. Can't wait to visit them again. Thank you.

by Jake on Amish Farm Stay
Review title: Fantastic
Stayed At: Killdear

We had a wonderful time at the Killdeer farm. The house and farm far exceeded our expectations. The house was beautiful, newly renovated very spacious and very clean. We had more than enough room for our family of nine.

The Esh family was very warm and welcoming and my kids had a great time holding the puppies and feeding a calf a bottle.

This was definitely on our list of all time great experiences and we can't wait to do it again!

I'm glad you had such a good time at the Killdeer Farm Guesthouse!

by David on Amish Farm Stay
Review title: Excellent
Stayed At: Amish Homestay

Our stay with Ben and his family was so much fun. His wife served us a delicious breakfast every morning, and dinner when we first arrived. They both were so nice and fun to talk with. Ben gave us a ride in his buggy and also gave us a tour of several places in the area, including a farm, quilt shop, and a road stop. Ben is retired so he has more time to spend with visitors. My daughter and I really enjoyed the stay.

Thank you for your recview! You may find information & photos of this lodging on our sister website.

by Hannah on Amish Farm Stay
August 2019
Review title: Wonderful Stay
Stayed At: Amish Homestay Bed & Breakfast (Ben and Emma's home)

My 14 year old daughter and I booked 2 nights at an Amish Bed and Breakfast (Ben and Emma's home) at the end of a week-long road trip from DC to Niagara Falls. The idea of two days totally off the grid, without electricity (and social media!) sounded unappealing to my daughter at first, but as soon as we met Ben and Emma, I knew we were in good hands and that we wouldn't miss our phones! Emma prepared a lovely meal for us on our first night. I had told her we were vegetarian, but that we could just eat the side dishes and not to worry, but Emma made a delicous and entirely vegetarian meal for us, including slaw, mashed potatoes, pickled beats, green beans, homemade bread and jam, and delicious peaches and chocolate zucchini bread with ice cream for dessert. It was the best meal of our weeklong trip! They don't normally serve dinner to guests, but since we were arriving on a Saturday evening and Sunday was church day and they wouldn't be serving us breakfast that morning, they wanted to make up for it with a full meal. Anyway, we explored the area on Sunday while they were at church (all day), but we enjoyed a delicious full breakfast on Monday morning--eggs, fruit, bread, and more! Then Ben took us on a buggy ride, after which we drove (in our car) to a couple of Amish farms and shops that we would never have found on our own. We both learned so much about the Amish during our short two day stay. Ben and Emma shared stories about their life together, their religion and customs, their children as well as their family history. Ben especially loves to talk about the Amish way of life--education, food, farminig practices, traditions, and more. We observed a traditional silent grace at the beginning and end of each meal. We asked questions about weddings (the bride doesn't wear white!), education (everyone goes to school through 8th grade only), and differences between the Amish and their Mennonite friends (Mennonites use tractors for farming; Amish use horses). Oh, and we learned that we are referred to as "English" which we found to be quite amusing. Although they don't use electricity, they do have battery and solar-operated lights. We are definitely planning to go back!

Thank you for taking the time to write such a thoughtful & detailed review. I'm sure it will be very helpful to prospective future guests! (You may find information & photos of this lodging on our sister website.)

by Erin Larson on Amish Farm Stay
July, 2019
Review title: Pleasant View Wonderful
Stayed At: Pleasant View Farmhouse

My family thoroughly enjoyed the farm. It was super serene as it is not a working farm. The hosts spent lots of time chatting with us; which was our favorite part of the stay. We got to feed the horse and had free run of the whole property. My kids really enjoyed the bikes and the games that were available. The views and the scents were spectacular! We will definitely be returning someday.

Thank you for your review. I agree that Dave & Lena, and the Pleasant View Farm Guesthouse are wonderful!

by Hannah on Amish Farm Stay
July 2019
Review title: Amazing
Stayed At: The Dutch Homestead in Paradise

This place deserves more than 5 stars! The Fisher family were all so nice and we throughly enjoyed our stay! The apartment had everything we could’ve needed. Mary even left us homemade bread and jam which was amazing. We will definitely be staying here again!

We're glad you enjoyed your stay at the Dutch Homestead Guesthouse!

by Tiffany on Amish Farm Stay
June/July 2019
Review title: Lovely Time
Stayed At: Lapp Family Amish Guesthouse

We had a lovely time at the Lapp Family Amish Guesthouse. Our spacious house was welcoming along with the kind hosts. We enjoyed sharing conversation and desserts one evening around their firepit. Our children loved the provided toys and crib while we relished the beautiful views and generous hospitality. Our hosts, John and Linda, eagerly answered all our questions. Our family made many wonderful memories. Thanks so much!

Thsnk you for your review! For more information & photos of the Lapp Family Amish Guesthouse please visit our website.

by Erin on Amish Farm Stay
June 2019
Review title: Perfect getaway
Stayed At: Lapp Family Amish Guesthouse

My husband and I stayed here for a 2 night anniversary trip. The house was exceptionally clean and John was a fantastic host. The views are amazing and the house is conveniently located near everything we wanted to do. The basket of goodies on the table was a nice surprise. We can't wait to come back next year and plan to book this same house. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a quiet getaway.

Thank you for your review of the Lapp Family Amish Guesthouse!

by Joanne on Amish Farm Stay
June 2019
Review title: Accommodating
Stayed At: Country Road Flowers GuestHouse

To add to the review I just submitted for Country Road Flowers Guesthouse, I wanted to give a shout out to Dave for his coordination of our accommodations - both the lodging and the evening meal. We ate at a different location, Beacon Hollow, which was a very short and pleasant walk from our lodging. Our dinner was great fun! Loved the hospitality (Mary was very gracious), chatting with the other guests (from England, India, Germany, CA and then us), and the food kept coming and coming and coming - deeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeelicious! There wasn't anything we would change at all. We are excited to return for another Lancaster area visit!

Thank you for taking the time to submit your review. I'm glad your Amish experience in Lancaster County PA was so much to your liking!

by Joanne on Amish Farm Stay
June 2019
Review title: Home away from home
Stayed At: Country Road Flowers Guesthouse

We absolutely loved the location of the Country Roads Flowers Guesthouse and Beacon Hollow Farm (dinner). In fact, after our dinner, we walked back to our lodging.

The Guesthouse was very homey with plenty of space to spread out. Mary was quite accommodating and patient with all my questions. And her Shoo-Fly Muffins were a pleasant surprise and yummy!

There wasn't anything we would change at all. We can't wait to come back! Thanks again.

Page 1 of 6:
Translate »